| Member | Pick |
|---|---|
| Al Davis | Denver |
| Al Davis | Green Bay |
| Al Davis | Oakland |
| Bart | Miami |
| Boiler | Miami |
| Booth | Kansas City |
| Booth | Tampa Bay |
| Booth | Cleveland |
| Booth | San Francisco |
| Cali | Miami |
| Cameroon | Miami |
| Christine | New York Jets |
| Cleary | Miami |
| Draper | San Francisco |
| Fabes | San Francisco |
| Fabes | Carolina |
| Fabes | Kansas City |
| Fabes | St. Louis |
| Fabes | Pittsburgh |
| Fabes | Washington |
| Fabes | Seattle |
| Fabes | Miami |
| Goliath | Minnesota |
| Goliath | San Francisco |
| Goliath | Green Bay |
| Grandpa | Miami |
| Grover | Miami |
| Handbomb | New York |
| Handbomb | Denver |
| John | Oakland |
| LMac | New York Jets |
| melonhead | Miami |
| menzies | Miami |
| pants | Miami |
| Pielicker | Oakland |
| RUBE | Miami |
| Scouggie | Miami |
| Sheep Dog | Kansas City |
| Sheep Dog | Atlanta |
| Smitty | Kansas City |
| Smitty | Green Bay |
| Smitty | San Francisco |
| str8razor | Minnesota |
| str8razor | Kansas City |
| str8razor | Indianapolis |
| str8razor | Buffalo |
| str8razor | Pittsburgh |
| str8razor | Denver |
| str8razor | Seattle |
| str8razor | St. Louis |
| Swiss Miss | Tampa Bay |
| Swiss Miss | Denver |